Metallica followers are having a debate about which of the band’s songs are the saddest on Reddit.
Whereas Metallica are referred to as one of many “Huge 4” bands of the thrash steel scene, they’ve had loads of tender moments all through their discography. James Hetfield has written about loads of private issues to him, together with relationships and different inside struggles.
“It’s simply emotions inside,” Hetfield stated throughout a Swedish interview in 1996. “We write what comes naturally.”
A fan took to the band’s Reddit web page to ask different metalheads which Metallica music they discover absolutely the saddest they usually began the dialog with the …And Justice for All hit “One.”
We highlighted a number of the high music picks beneath, added a number of the commentary from different followers and famous the saddest lyrics beneath as effectively.
“To Dwell Is to Die”
One of many selections with the best quantity of upvotes is one other music from …And Justice for All — “To Dwell Is to Die.” The observe is the longest on the album and has solely been performed dwell by the band a small handful of instances, in accordance with Setlist.fm’s Tour Statistics on Metallica.
READ MORE: Metallica Announce 2025 Tour Dates With Pantera, Limp Bizkit + Extra
The person who urged the music didn’t present any context with their alternative, however one other fan replied, “Wonderful take” with a tear emoji.
Saddest lyrics:
When a person lies he murders some a part of the world
These are the pale deaths
Which males miscall their lives
All this I can not bear to witness any longer
Can’t the dominion of salvation
Take me residence
Metallica, “To Dwell Is to Die”
“Fade to Black”
“Fade to Black” from Journey the Lightning acquired essentially the most upvotes on the whole thread and it’s not arduous to see why. It’s one of many band’s extra fashionable unhappy songs and is their ninth most-played observe dwell.
“What makes this so unhappy is how intricate the lyrics are — and James was solely 20 or 21 years previous when he wrote that. So younger,” one particular person wrote.
“Till you understand he’s speaking about some gig tools that was stolen and that was his feelings from it,” another person responded, including, “The music itself has been stated to have helped tons of individuals undergo despair so I’m not gonna knock the message it can provide to a selected particular person.”
Saddest lyrics:
I’ve misplaced the need to dwell
Merely nothing extra to offer
There may be nothing extra for me
Want the top to set me free
Metallica, “Fade to Black”
“Mama Mentioned”
One other fashionable response was a observe from 1996’s Load, “Mama Mentioned.”
Hetfield wrote the observe about his relationship along with his mother, who died when he was an adolescent. Metallica have by no means carried out it throughout an precise live performance, but it surely was performed on a couple of tv specials within the ’90s.
This observe acquired loads of upvotes from fellow followers on the thread too.
Saddest lyrics:
I took your love without any consideration
And all of the stuff you stated to me, yeah-yeah
I want your arms to welcome me
However a chilly stone’s all I see
Metallica, “Mama Mentioned”
“Fixxxer”
There appears to be a operating theme right here that Metallica’s longest songs are their saddest, as “Fixxxer,” the closing observe on 1997’s Reload, was additionally talked about in the course of the dialogue.
“There’s no decision, simply one other pin jabbed on him,” the one that urged the music wrote, referencing the music’s lyrics.
“This. He sings from the angle of a drained, damaged man. (In all probability himself. Late ’90s have been a really turbulent time for the band),” one other fan responded. “Each time it looks as if he’s about to get higher, he suffers one other hardship. It pulls him down decrease than he was earlier than. All of the whereas, he’s begging this energy that hurts him to at the least heal the ache from his previous so he can at the least discover the energy to hold on with out that further weight.”
Saddest lyrics:
Simply when all appears advantageous and I’m pain-free
You jab one other pin, jab one other pin in me
Metallica, “Fixxxer”
Different Tracks Talked about
“Low Man’s Lyric” from Reload, “The Day That By no means Comes” from Dying Magnetic and “My Buddy of Distress” from Metallica have been amongst a number of the different tracks talked about in the course of the dialogue.
Learn the complete thread right here to see extra.
The Most Performed Track Dwell Off Each Metallica Album
The songs you’re more than likely to listen to at a Metallica present from each album.
Gallery Credit score: Joe DiVita